Transportation

Should I keep my old car?

Calculate if it's smarter to keep repairing your current car or replace it with something newer based on repair costs, reliability, and value.

By ShouldICalc Team

Updated January 2025 · See our methodology

Your Numbers

Your Results

Annual Savings

$0 – $0

per year

5-Year Savings

$0 – $0

Break Even

— months

💡 Calculating...

Enter your numbers above to see personalized results.

Trade-offs to Consider

Every decision has pros and cons. Here's what to weigh:

Money

Repairs are usually cheaper than car payments. But at some point, reliability becomes a money pit.
Time

Old cars need more maintenance attention. But you avoid the time cost of car shopping.
Quality

New cars have better features and safety. Old cars are familiar and known quantities.
Convenience

New means reliable. Old means potential breakdowns and repair shop visits.

Related Calculators

Should I adopt or buy a pet?

Compare the costs of adopting vs buying a dog or cat, including upfront fees, health guarantees, and long-term expenses.

Should I shop at Aldi or my regular grocery store?

Calculate how much you'd save switching to Aldi from traditional supermarkets like Kroger, Publix, or Safeway.

Should I bulk buy staples?

Calculate if buying in bulk actually saves money after factoring in storage, waste, and the true cost of tying up cash in inventory.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is repair cost too high?

A common rule: if repairs exceed 50% of the car's value, consider replacing. But this oversimplifies. A $2,000 repair on a $4,000 car that then lasts 3 more years is better than buying a $400/month car payment.

How many miles is too many?

Modern cars can last 200,000-300,000 miles with proper maintenance. Mileage alone isn't the issue—maintenance history is. A well-maintained 200k car can outlast a neglected 100k car.

Should I fix a car before selling?

Usually no. You rarely recover repair costs in sale price. Sell as-is and let the buyer decide. Exception: safety issues that prevent legal sale.

What repairs indicate it's time to replace?

Red flags: transmission failure ($3,000-5,000), engine problems, multiple simultaneous issues, rust in structural areas, electrical gremlins. These suggest the car is wearing out systemically, not just needing routine repair.

Should You Keep Repairing That Old Car? A Decision Framework

Staring at a big repair bill for your aging car triggers a universal question: should I fix it or replace it? Here’s how to think through the decision rationally.

The Fundamental Comparison

Keeping your current car:

Repair costs (known or estimated)
Ongoing maintenance
Lower insurance costs
No car payments
No new debt

Replacing with newer car:

Monthly payment: $300-600
Higher insurance: $50-150/month more
New car warranty
Better reliability (probably)
Modern safety features
New debt for years

The 50% Rule (And Why It’s Wrong)

You’ve probably heard: “Don’t repair if it costs more than 50% of the car’s value.”

This is flawed because:

It ignores what you’d spend on replacement
Car value and transportation value are different
A reliable $5,000 car provides the same transportation as a $30,000 car

Better framework: Compare repair cost to what you’d spend on replacement over the same period.

The Real Math

Scenario: $2,500 repair on a car worth $5,000

Option A: Make the repair

Repair cost: $2,500
Assume car lasts 24 more months
Cost per month: $104/month
Plus maintenance: $100/month
Total: $204/month

Option B: Replace the car

Down payment: $3,000
Monthly payment: $400
Higher insurance: $75/month
First 24 months: $11,400
Cost per month: $475/month

Repair saves $271/month or $6,500 over two years.

When to Keep Repairing

The repair extends reliable life: A new transmission in an otherwise solid car can add 100,000+ miles of life.

The car is fundamentally reliable: Toyota, Honda, and some other brands remain reliable even at high mileage. Known issues are better than unknown.

You’re close to paying off a loan: Once the loan is done, you’ll have payment-free transportation. Don’t reset that clock.

Repair is routine maintenance: Timing belts, water pumps, brakes, and suspension aren’t problems—they’re expected wear items.

You don’t drive much: Low annual mileage means even an older car lasts many more years.

When to Replace

Multiple expensive repairs loom: If you need transmission work AND the engine has issues AND the A/C died, the car is failing systemically.

Safety is compromised: Frame rust, failing brakes, or airbag issues aren’t worth risking. Safety trumps economics.

Repair costs exceed monthly payments: If you’re spending $500/month on repairs, a new car payment might bring more reliability.

The car has become unreliable: Breaking down frequently creates stress, missed work, and hidden costs (towing, rentals, etc.).

Life circumstances changed: Need more space, better fuel economy, or specific features? Sometimes needs evolve.

Major Repairs: Worth It or Not?

Usually Worth Repairing:

Repair	Cost	Worth It?
Timing belt + water pump	$800-1,200	Yes - extends life significantly
Brakes (all four)	$400-800	Yes - safety and expected wear
Suspension work	$500-1,500	Yes - improves safety and ride
A/C compressor	$800-1,200	Depends - comfort vs necessity

Consider Carefully:

Repair	Cost	Worth It?
Transmission rebuild	$2,500-4,500	Maybe - if car otherwise solid
Head gasket	$1,500-3,000	Maybe - can indicate deeper issues
Catalytic converter	$1,500-3,000	Maybe - required for registration

Usually Not Worth It:

Repair	Cost	Worth It?
Engine replacement	$4,000-8,000	Rarely - often costs more than car
Transmission + other major	$5,000+	No - too much in aging car
Frame/rust repair	Varies	No - usually can’t fix properly

The High-Mileage Myth

Many people think 100,000 miles = end of life. This is outdated.

Modern cars with proper maintenance:

150,000 miles: Still reliable for most cars
200,000 miles: Common for Japanese brands
250,000+ miles: Achievable with care

What matters more than mileage:

Maintenance history (oil changes, timing belt, fluids)
Climate (rust belt vs dry climate)
Driving type (highway miles are easier than city)
Brand reliability (some cars just last longer)

The Replacement Cost Reality

Before replacing, understand the real cost:

Buying a new car:

Down payment: $3,000-5,000
Monthly payment (5 years): $400-600
Higher insurance: $50-150/month more
Total 5-year cost: $30,000-45,000

Buying a used car:

Down payment: $2,000-3,000
Monthly payment (4-5 years): $300-400
Total 5-year cost: $18,000-25,000

Keeping your car:

Repairs: $1,000-3,000/year
Lower insurance: $50-100/month
Total 5-year cost: $8,000-20,000

The numbers strongly favor keeping a reliable old car.

The Right Mindset

Think like a fleet manager: Big companies keep vehicles until operating cost exceeds replacement cost. They don’t replace cars because they’re “old”—they replace them when the math says so.

Your car is transportation, not status: If you’re replacing because you’re embarrassed by an old car, that’s a $25,000+ image purchase.

Every car becomes unreliable eventually: The question is whether yours has reached that point, not whether it might someday.

Making Your Decision

Keep the car if:

Repair brings reliable years ahead
Repair cost < 6 months of car payments
Car has good reliability history
No safety concerns
You’re comfortable with older vehicle

Replace the car if:

Multiple systems failing
Safety is compromised
Repairs exceed car payments monthly
Reliability is constantly in question
Life needs have genuinely changed

If You Decide to Replace

Maximize the old car:

Sell privately (get 20-30% more than trade-in)
Be honest about condition
Clean it thoroughly for photos
Price fairly based on actual condition

Buy smart:

2-3 year old used car = best value
Get a pre-purchase inspection
Avoid rolling negative equity into new loan
Don’t over-finance (5 years max)

The best financial outcome is almost always keeping a reliable car as long as possible. But there’s a point where reliability dies—that’s when replacement makes sense.